Policy Recommendations for EU Instruments on Permanent Removals

Oct 17, 2024

To achieve climate neutrality, humanity needs to eliminate almost all anthropogenic emissions. Towards that end, permanent carbon dioxide removals (CDR) will be needed to compensate for the unavoidable emissions from sectors society deems vital and to lower atmospheric concentrations of greenhouse gases caused by historical emissions.

Ranging from industrial to nature-based processes, carbon removal techniques are not created equal. One major factor to distinguish them is their duration of carbon dioxide storage.

Biogenic sequestration by natural ecosystems that sequester carbon from the atmosphere and store it in biomass or soils are vulnerable to human and natural disturbances. Due to the risk that the carbon ecosystems store will be rereleased into the atmosphere, biogenic sequestration should be considered temporary. Natural ecosystems should be protected and their carbon uptake enhanced, but they should not be used to compensate residual anthropogenic emissions. Carbon removal methods that can store carbon for at least several centuries should be considered permanent and can therefore be used to compensate for residual emissions.

Support for carbon removals must not undermine efforts to slash emissions. To avoid this and to recognise the distinction between biogenic sequestration and permanent CDR, different targets and policies are necessary for emissions reduction, biogenic sequestration and permanent removals. The EU needs a clear and comprehensive strategy that is mindful of the risks, challenges and opportunities of supporting the development and scale-up of a sufficient supply of permanent removals.

The CO2ol Down project, comprising representatives from academia, industry, and civil society, met during three full-day co-creation workshops and suggested the building blocks in this paper to structure an appropriate strategy for permanent removals.

Dr Alice Evatt was a co-author of the paper. Please see the PDF for the full list of authors.

Publication details
Theme(s)
Carbon dioxide removal
Type(s)
Policy paper
Author(s)
Evatt, Alice
Year(s)
2024

Latest news

UK Government Voluntary Carbon and Nature Markets policy consolidates action on nature and climate, but risks compromising urgent mitigation of climate change and preventing and repairing nature loss, say ONZ researchers
UK Government Voluntary Carbon and Nature Markets policy consolidates action on nature and climate, but risks compromising urgent mitigation of climate change and preventing and repairing nature loss, say ONZ researchers

Oxford, 23 June 2025 Researchers from the Leverhulme Centre for Nature Recovery, Oxford Net Zero and Oxford Sustainable Finance Group have submitted feedback to the UK Government’s ‘Voluntary Carbon and Nature Markets: Raising Integrity’ ... Read more

Job opening: Serviced Emissions Research & Engagement Manager
Job opening: Serviced Emissions Research & Engagement Manager

The Oxford Net Zero Engagement Team is recruiting for a Serviced Emissions Research & Engagement Manager. This pivotal role will lead a high-impact initiative focused on advancing the understanding and integration of “serviced emissions” ... Read more

New Oxford Report: Carbon Capture and Storage Without Taxpayer Billions Is Possible
New Oxford Report: Carbon Capture and Storage Without Taxpayer Billions Is Possible

Oxford Net Zero and Carbon Balance researchers reveal the risks of the current UK CCS policy mix and explore how a carbon storage mandate on fossil fuel producers could help the UK meet its climate targets while protecting public finances A ... Read more

See more news and events