The influence of climate change advisory bodies on political debates: evidence from the UK Committee on Climate Change

Aug 1, 2023

Climate change advisory bodies are rapidly proliferating around the world, often with statutory underpinning. While they are argued to be an important component of effective climate governance, few studies have systematically assessed their political influence. Using the UK Committee on Climate Change (CCC) as a case, this paper investigates how such bodies influence political debates on climate change. To do so, we build an original dataset of all CCC mentions in UK Parliamentary proceedings from 2008–2018. We find that CCC analysis is used by all major political parties, that its influence has grown over time and that it has influenced policy debates both within its statutory remit (carbon budgets) and more broadly (energy policy and flood defence spending). Furthermore, most politicians have been supportive of the CCC. They have utilized the information it produces to hold government accountable and to argue for more ambitious policy. We find little evidence that CCC analysis is politicized or that it merely functions as a ‘legitimiser’, providing justification for the government’s pre-decided policy choices. Instead, we find that the CCC functions primarily as a knowledge broker, offering trusted information to policymakers, and at times as a policy entrepreneur. Overall, the CCC experience demonstrates that climate change advisory bodies can play a key role in climate governance.

Publication details
Theme(s)
The urgency of zero
Type(s)
Research paper
Author(s)
Fankhauser, Sam
Year(s)
2021
Climate Policy

Latest news

Young climate leaders funded by Oxford Net Zero and SSEE to attend COP29
Young climate leaders funded by Oxford Net Zero and SSEE to attend COP29

The inaugural cohort of Global Youth Climate Training (GYCT) Programme bursary recipients will arrive in Baku, Azerbaijan in the coming days, ready to participate in their individual streams of work at COP29.  The GYCT, a collaboration between ... Read more

Serviced emissions: Placing professional services at the heart of Net Zero
Serviced emissions: Placing professional services at the heart of Net Zero

This piece was originally published by the Smith of School of Enterprise and the Environment. Republished with permission.    As our world races against time to halve global emissions by 2030, a critical and overlooked catalyst is ... Read more

Call for participants: “Unlocking the power of youth to develop equity in net-zero governance”
Call for participants: “Unlocking the power of youth to develop equity in net-zero governance”

Oxford Net Zero's Engagement Team have an open call for youth aged 18-35 years old to participate in a new 8-month long research project to embed equity criteria into net-zero governance.  There is perhaps no single demographic that will be ... Read more

See more news and events